Fear and Distrust
The Silent Barriers to Organizational Change
Change.
It’s inevitable these days. In fact, when I talk to leaders and teams these days, we talk about the fact that change is no longer a project you undertake from time to time. Change is now an ongoing process. An iterative effort that every leader needs to be prepared to lead for the long-term.
Two of the most significant and often overlooked barriers to leading successful change and transformation efforts are fear and distrust.
The Underlying Issues
Fear in the workplace stems from various sources. Employees may fear losing their jobs, being seen as incompetent or incapable, being unable to adapt to new systems or expectations, or facing new challenges for which they aren’t fully prepared. This fear can lead to resistance, whether passive or active. Fearful employees are less likely to embrace new change initiatives or adapt well to modifications made during a major transformation process.
Distrust, on the other hand, arises when there is a lack of confidence in leadership or among colleagues. Often distrust is a result of negative past experiences, such as prior failed change initiatives and unmet expectations. Distrust also often emerges when a leader is less than fully transparent with their teams, or when the team doesn’t feel that their leadership has the team’s best interests at heart. Unfortunately, distrust breeds skepticism that can stifle or even cripple innovation and change initiatives.
The Impact on Change Initiatives
Fear and distrust can severely undermine change initiatives. They often lead to poor communication, with employees holding back from asking important questions, and leaders glossing over major potential challenges. Both parties need to be able to share transparently, but when trust is low and fear is high, that kind of open dialogue rarely happens. This communication breakdown results in misunderstandings, missed expectations, disappointment, and other complications that can derail a change initiative.
One of the other major negative outcomes of a culture of fear and distrust is disengagement. This issue, in my opinion, might be the more critical concern. That’s because disengagement isn’t just about what happens during a change effort. Unfortunately, when an employee becomes disengaged, she doesn’t just become disengaged from a specific project. It’s more likely that this disengagement will permeate that employee’s overall work, rendering them less effective in all areas of work. Disengagement ultimately leads to reduced productivity and potentially even increased turnover.
Overcoming Fear and Distrust
Overcoming fear and distrust in your organization requires that leaders first acknowledge and address the underlying issues. Often that begins with a leader fostering and cultivating a true culture of transparency and authenticity. This means increased levels of open and honest communication, frank discussions about the need for change, the reasons for the change, what the potential benefits and the risks might be to change, etc. This requires a leader to talk about things that they might be uncertain about, and which might require them to make some educated and informed guesses. That’s often uncomfortable for leaders who want to “know everything” before they speak. But if they don’t move forward in faith and share what is known and unknown, they’ll never increase the transparency across their organization.
During this process of increasing transparency, the other issue that leaders need to face and allow for is employee feedback. In many cases, leaders work to limit employee feedback because they are afraid that it doesn’t align with organizational objectives and that it might create negative backlash across the organization. However, stifling feedback, questions, and objections across the team has the potential to do more harm than good. Open and honest dialogue around your change initiatives and regular updates that allow employees to voice their fears and concerns will yield to greater levels of trust and transparency.
Leadership must also demonstrate empathy and support. Recognizing the emotional and psychological impacts of change and providing the necessary support, whether through training, coaching, or other resources, can help employees feel more secure and capable of navigating the transition.
Building trust requires consistent and reliable actions from leadership. This means following through on promises, being accountable for mistakes, and creating an environment of fairness in the workplace. When employees see that their leaders are trustworthy, they are more likely to support and participate in change initiatives.
Conclusion
Fear and distrust are potent obstacles to organizational change, but they are not insurmountable. By fostering a culture of transparency, empathy, and reliability, leaders can mitigate these negative emotions and build a more resilient and adaptable organization. In a world where change is the only constant, overcoming fear and distrust is not just beneficial—it is imperative for long-term success.
Accelerate Your Leadership Impact in 90-Days
If you want to become a leader of significant impact, you need to take the 90-Day Leader’s Journey. In this 90-day email course I’ll share with you 90 key insights on leadership Character, Culture, and Competence that I use to train leadership teams in professional service firms every day — and that you can use to accelerate your own leadership impact!